Sedans like the Honda City and Toyota Yaris remain popular choices in Pakistan due to their blend of comfort, performance, and affordability. However, when it comes to fuel efficiency, which one offers better value?
To find out, a real-world fuel economy test was conducted between the 2021 Honda City 1.5L and the 2024 Toyota Yaris 1.5L on both urban roads and highways in Lahore. Let’s see which sedan takes the lead in fuel savings.
Fuel Efficiency Test – Methodology
For an unbiased comparison, both cars were:
✔ Filled to full tanks at the same petrol station.
✔ Driven on identical routes, including congested city roads and open highways.
✔ Checked for fuel consumption after completing the journey.
The aim was to assess real-world fuel averages instead of relying on manufacturer claims.
Honda City vs. Toyota Yaris – Head-to-Head Comparison
Honda City 1.5L (2021 Model)
- Engine & Transmission: 1.5L engine, 5-speed CVT
- Company-Claimed Fuel Efficiency:
- City: 12 km/l
- Highway: 16 km/l
- Weight: 1,140 kg
✔ Pros:
- Lighter weight improves city handling.
- Reliable performance with a comfortable ride.
✖ Cons:
- Slightly lower highway efficiency.
- Older design compared to Yaris.
Toyota Yaris 1.5L (2024 Model)
- Engine & Transmission: 1.5L engine, 7-speed CVT
- Company-Claimed Fuel Efficiency:
- City: 12 km/l
- Highway: 16 km/l
- Weight: 1,180 kg
✔ Pros:
- 7-speed CVT ensures better RPM control, enhancing fuel efficiency.
- Improved aerodynamics for better highway performance.
✖ Cons:
- Slightly heavier weight.
- Higher price compared to Honda City.
Performance Results – Real-World Fuel Economy
1. City Driving (Lahore Traffic Conditions)
- Honda City: 11-12 km/l
- Toyota Yaris: 13 km/l ✅ (Better fuel economy in stop-and-go traffic)
2. Highway Drive (Ring Road & Open Stretches)
- Honda City: 16 km/l ✅ (Better highway performance)
- Toyota Yaris: 15 km/l
3. Key Differences in Features
✔ Honda City – Lighter weight makes it easier to maneuver in traffic but can affect highway stability.
✔ Toyota Yaris – 7-speed CVT optimizes RPM shifts, providing better control and fuel economy.
Price Comparison – Which Offers Better Value?
| Car Model | Price (PKR, On-Road) |
|---|---|
| Honda City 2021 | 5.9 – 6.0 million (More budget-friendly) |
| Toyota Yaris 2024 | 6.5 million (Higher cost but better features) |
✔ Honda City is a more affordable option, making it ideal for budget-conscious buyers.
✔ Toyota Yaris justifies its higher price with better fuel efficiency and modern features, making it a smarter investment for highway drivers.
Final Verdict – Which One Should You Buy?
✔ Buy Toyota Yaris if:
- You prioritize fuel savings, especially for highway travel.
- You prefer a modern design with advanced technology.
✔ Buy Honda City if:
- You need an affordable sedan for city driving.
- You prefer a lighter car with reliable performance.
While both cars offer similar fuel efficiency, the Toyota Yaris provides better mileage in city driving, making it a better choice for urban commuters. However, if affordability is a priority, the Honda City remains a solid contender.